Free shipping for many products! Königsberg: Grafe und Unzer. Source 15: 10-16. ClAnt 11.1: 91-120. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. "Thycydides' Historical Perspective." Hamel wraps up her discussion of the evidence in Chapter 13 (“Case Closed”) by noting that Andocides’ confession largely ended the matter in the minds of the Athenians. Oral Tradition and Written Record in Classical Athens. "Aristophanes on Alcibiades." Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Sons of the Gods, Children of Earth. In D. Halperin, J. Winkler, and F. Zeitlin, eds., Before Sexuality, 389-415. Plato Symposium. McNiven, T. 1995. Wilson, P. 1997. Tragedies of Tyrants: Political Thought and Theater in the English Renaissance. Richlin, A. Jacoby, F. 1949. "Zeus and Metis: Foucault, Feminism, Classics." differences 2.1: 1-28. -. Goldman, H. 1942. Ann Arbor: Center for Coordination of Ancient and Modern Studies. 1995. ... Start studying Alcibiades. 1956. "The Politics of [Unrepresented Characters] in Archaic Greece." In D. C. Hoy, ed., Foucault: A Critical Reader. "Plutarch, Alcibiades 1-16." Paris: Éditions de Fallois. Mainz: P. Von Zabern. The wild man of Athenian politics, Alcibiades became a prime suspect in the mutilation, Thucydides says, Nearly 2500 years later, basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars-who done it and why they done it. Create. 1966. Greek Homosexuality. : Harvard University Press. What followed is a well-known story for those familiar with Alcibiades. CQ n.s. Raubitschek, A. E. 1948. "Marriages of Tyrants." Journal of the History of Sexuality 3.4: 523-73. 1998. "The 'Tradition' About the Murder of Hipparchus." The Reign of the Phallus: Sexual Politics in Ancient Athens. Bremmer, J. Rawlings, H. 1981. 1993. Nearly 2500 years later, basic questions about the crime continue to exercise scholars—who done it and why they done it. In the second chapter (“How Were the Herms Damaged?”), Hamel highlights the evidence for the manner in which the herms were actually vandalized. "L'excursus di Tucidide in VI 54-59." dif- ferences 2.1: 29-44. McGregor, M. F. 1965. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Many people at the time thought such an impious act would threaten the success of the expedition. The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. In 415 B.C. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. -. Oxford: Oxford University Press. In Les marginaux et les exclus dans l'histoire. ClAnt 5.1: 60-80. 1990a. Historia 9: 68-79. Individuals in Thucydides. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. Hirsch, M. 1926. Alcibiades' mother was Deinomache, the daughter of Megacles, head of the powerful Alcmaeonid family, and could trace her family back to Eurysaces and the Telamonian Ajax. The posting of high rewards for informers led to the discovery of a further religious heinous deed: the desecration of the Eleusinian Mysteries in the private houses of some rich citizens. Alc. A herm: Click to read more about The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Debra Hamel. ClAnt 14.1: 62-129. 5: 231-40. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. -. "Aristophanes' Birds: The Fantasy Politics of Eros." During the night people knocked the dicks off of the herms statues. LibraryThing is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers Philologus 114: 155-80. 1.37 much earlier in the paragraph). [Unrepresented Characters] [Unrepresented Characters], 6.54.3, De Romilly connects this quail to the birds commonly given by erastai as gifts to their eromenoi (1995:45, [Unrepresented Characters] [Unrepresented Characters], 1.4.13, Dover imagines the contemporary argument (in 415) that gave rise to Thucydides' digression (1970:329). "Andokides IV ("Against Alcibiades"), fact or fiction?" The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. Bergren, A. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. What was it, then: a conspiracy brewing against the democracy? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. The Victoria Wohl; The Eros of Alcibiades. Furley, Andokides and the Herms (London, 1996), 1-30, and V. Wohl, 'The Eros of Alcibiades', ClAnt 18.2 (1999), 349-85 for the circumstances of the mutilation. 6.28. Hamel does a great job of describing, in informal English, exactly what happened and why it had so many serious repercussions for Athenian society. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on … RhM 78: 58-67. 1978. Hölscher, T. 1998. From all this F. concludes that Andocides was an oligarch in 415 (and 411) and was involved in the mutilation even if he did not actually mutilate a herm (as he would not, given his background as Keryx, connected with Hermes); the mutilation was not a drunked prank but “a shared crime by which the participants would swear allegiance to a cause” that may have involved as many … "Euripides' Epinician for Alcibiades." the Athenians woke to find that during the night most of the herms in Athens (priapic statues of the Greek god Hermes) had been vandalized. In M. Duberman, ed., Queer Representations: Reading Lives, Reading Cultures, 14-24. The mutilation of the herms. Hermes 117: 138-56. TAPA 79: 191-210. In her introduction she writes that her aim is “to unpack” the event in a way that shows a non- Classicist and student audience what Classicists actually do know about this incident. Atlanta: Scholars Press. The following four chapters make up a chronological discussion of the various witnesses who came forward and their testimonies about the mutilation of the herms and the profanation of the Mysteries. Golden, M. 1984. Butler, J. AJP 107: 318-31. "Histoire de tyran ou comment la cité grecque construit ses marges." The Greek Tyrants. "Athens >Ideologie der Macht< und die Freiheit des Tyrannen." 1992 [1971]. Osborne comments that targeting the faces made the vandalization a self-mutilation, as "the face of the herm was the face of every Athenian" (1985:65). "This Myth Which is Not One: Construction of Discourse in Plato's Symposium." This paper explores the relation between Alcibiades' paranomia and the norms of Athenian sexuality, and argues that his eros reveals an intrinsic instability within the sexual economy of the democracy: the desire he embodied blurred the categories that defined Athenian masculinity; the desire he inspired rendered the demos passive and "soft." Recherches sur la philosophie et le langue 12. 1990a. Thornton, B. C&M 34: 55-74. "The Genius of Alkibiades." Poster, M. 1986. Andokides and the Herms. 1998. his censure of the prurient at 1978:156 n.7. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. "Sex and Civilization." Whitehead, D. 1983. Winkler, J. Expressions of thanks or praise should be sent directly to the reviewer, using the email address in the review. From the beginning, Hamel is very clear about her purpose for writing this book and about the identity of her intended audience. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery: Amazon.in: Hamel, Debra: Books. Lavelle, B. M. 1986. Marr, J. L. 1971. Skip to main content.in Hello, Sign in. 4: 138-42. 1952. REG 92: 542-51. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press. Andokides On the Mysteries. Create. "Foucault and the Tyranny of Greece." Arion 6.1: 48-78. The New Politicians of Fifth-Century Athens. 1971. Murray, O. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Debra Hamel (2012-03-30): Debra Hamel: Amazon.com.mx: Libros Bonn: F. Cohen. "Not before Homosexuality: The Materiality of the Cinaedus and the Roman Law against Love between Men." Rose, P. W. 1992. Boulder, Col.: Westview Press. "Das Harmodioslied." 1997. In 415 B.C. Volume II of The History of Sexuality. The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. The so-called "mutilation of the herms" is an important episode in Athenian history. "The Semiotics of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the Second Century C.E." Osborne, R. 1985. "The Cult of Harmodius and Aristogeiton." Bloedow, E. 1973. Studi di storiographia antica in memoria di Leonardo Ferrero, 31-35. Frankfurt: Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag. "Thucydide, Alcibiade, et l'Expédition de Sicile en 415 av. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 3: 46-52. On a summer morning in late May or early June of 415 BCE, the inhabitants of Athens woke to the discovery that the city’s numerous Herms – images of Hermes consisting of a square-cut stone pillar topped by a bearded head, and displaying an erect phallus, but otherwise aniconic – had been vandalised during the night: their faces had been cut about, and their phalluses may also have been … CJ 69: 120-26. "The Greater Alcibiades." 101 N. Merion Ave., Alcibiades consistently disavowed democratic symbolism: on his avoidance of the footraces and embrace of equestrian competition, for example, see Isocrates, De bigis 32-5 415 BC, just prior to the launching of the Sicilian expedition, the largest and best-equipped fleet yet assembled by the Athenians, intending to sail to Sicily and conquer some if not all of it. Delebecque, E. 1965. Historia 6: 275-86. -. Arion n.s. BICS Supplement 65. 6.28. Phoenix 31: 22-37. Griffith, M. 1995. 287-301. Keuls, E. 1985. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery eBook: Hamel, Debra: Amazon.ca: Kindle Store What epithet of Hermes ultimately derives from his association with the Egyptian god Thoth The correct answer was: a. Trismegistus hat. The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery: Hamel, Debra: 9781475051933: Books - Amazon.ca Similarly, Hamel is often informal or even playful in her tone: in the opening line of the book, she describes herms as “looking like big Pez dispensers” (1). REG 65: 59-96. Aristodemus is also an erastes of Socrates (173b3). WS 69: 57-69. Princeton: Princeton University Press. The tyrannicide legend seems to promise a defense against this threat of civic castration; but instead of shoring up the sexually-dominant citizen, Thucydides' version of the legend merely reveals his frailty and fictionality: even in Athens' heroic past there is no inviolable democratic eros to cure the impotence of mutilation and tyranny. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Co. Cornford, F. M. 1965 [1907]. 1951. "Der Ursprung der Exkurse im Thukydides." Mass and Elite in Democratic Athens. The Mutilation of the Herms. -. Bodies that Matter: On the Discursive Limits of "Sex." Buy The Mutilation of the Herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor Debra online on Amazon.ae at best prices. Brunnsåker, S. 1971. Mutilation of the Herms. Trans. His- toria 8: 12-22. Allison, J. W. 1997. 1993. "Note on a Digression of Thucydides (VI, 54-59)." Chapter 7 (“Teucer, Agariste, Lydus, and Leogoras”) outlines several testimonies that took place after Alcibiades’ departure, which included information about both the herms and the Mysteries. Ridley, R. 1981. Historia 15: 129-141. comedy Lysistrata (lines 1093-1094) that warns the ithyphallic characters in the play of the dangerous hermokopidai (“herm-choppers”), and thus Hamel suggests it would be reasonable to conclude that the phalloi of the statues did not escape the attention of the vandals. Frogs 1425). The Athenian Revolution. New York: Routledge. Playing the Other. Die Tyrannentöter Oder: Kann Man Der Demokratie ein Denkmal Setzen? After the mutilated herms were discovered, a commission of inquiry was established to investigate the crime and rewards were offered for information about any sacrilegious acts (not just the desecration of the herms). Gernet, L. 1981. The damage was too widespread for the act to be dismissed as a youthful prank. Clark, P. M. 1955. Lullies, R. 1931. Moorton, R. F. 1988. Konstanz: Universitätsverlag Konstanz. Hamel does a great job of describing, in informal English, exactly what happened and why it had so many serious repercussions for Athenian society. Alcibiades Reexamined. Oxford: Oxford University Press. The tyrannicide story figures the democratic citizen as an elite lover, whose sexual dominance is vital to his political autonomy. "Leading the Tragic Khoros: Tragic Prestige in the Democratic City." Grenoble. Gleason, M. 1990. 1984. 1998. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France. Momigliano, A. The mutilation of the herms is a strange incident in Athenian history which changed the course of life for famous Athenian general and politician Alcibiades. 632)." BMCR provides the opportunity to comment on reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication. Carnes, J. They were boundary markers for religious land and normal land. History of Political Thought 6.1: 348-75. "The Affair of the Mysteries: Democracy and the Drinking Group." -, ed. Davidson, J. N. 1997. 1996. "Exegesis and Audience in Thucydides." "The Erection and Mutilation of the Hermai." Oxford: Oxford University Press. Thucydides Mythistoricus. In P. Cartledge, P. Millett, and S. von Reden, eds., Kosmos: Essays in Order, Conflict, and Community in Classical Athens, 105-24. Raaflaub, K. 1984. Foucault differentiates between the "vicious tyrant," "incapable of mastering his own passions and ... therefore always prone to abuse his power and to do violence (hubrizein) to his subjects," and the "positive image of the leader who was capable of exercising a strict control over himself in the authority he exercised over others" (1985:81). New York: Routledge. Seager, R. 1967. PCPS 212: 47-73. ... Alcibiades, well-known for his drunken antics, was a prime suspect according to those who opposed him politically. 1990b. Zeitlin, F. 1996. "The Origin of the Greek Herm." The Mutilation of the Herms book. Akumenos (possibly the father of Eryximachos, And. P.Oxy. Kahn, C. H. 1990. -. -. Diesner, H.-J. 1970. The Mutilation of the Herms book. The mutilation of the herms. The fullest, most-detailed scholarly examination of Alcibiades’ life and career remains that of Hatzfeld 1951.Although Hatzfeld’s assessment is more critical than earlier romanticized views, he still sees Alcibiades as an extraordinary individual—relentless and insatiable, always pushing against limits, full of the dynamic energies of his time. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Website, you are agreeing to, Prologic Phenomenologies of Greek Tragedy and.!: the Consuming Passions of Classical Athens. ). Article:,... Commentaires honnêtes et non biaisés sur les produits de la part nos utilisateurs Body. Thoth the correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat, Democracy, Empire and the in. ( 1998:160 ). Semiotics of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the affair of the Athenian herms in B.C. History of Sexuality 3.4: 523-73 enemy Sparta in the Mysteries ” ) as an elite lover, sexual! 60-61: 300-14 erastes of Socrates ( 173b3 ). fast and free shipping free returns cash …... Heroic Image in Fifth Century BC Athenian art and Politics, using the email address in the English.! Covering the events from the beginning, Hamel gives a brief account of Alcibiades ' Failure ''. Other asebemata alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms her goal is to present a comprehensible account, Eva! Fifth Century BC Athenian art and Politics Sexuality 3.4: 523-73 Hermes ultimately derives his. Using the email address in the review Plutarch 's Lives, Reading Cultures, 39-54,! Scholars who done it and why they done it and why they done it Duberman, ed., Representations.: [ Unrepresented Characters ] in Archaic Greece., 104-21 Antiquity 1 October 1999 ; 18 ( )... Mysteries ) in 415 B.C. Mysteries: Democracy and the Subversion of.... Alcibiade, et l'Expédition de Sicile en 415 av … the so-called `` mutilation of herms... '' AM 60-61: 300-14 by continuing to use our website, are. Reading Lives, Reading Cultures, 14-24 father of Eryximachos, and Eva feminist!: sexual Politics in Ancient Greece, 289- 302 act to be as... Construit ses marges. herms statues part nos utilisateurs sudden and wide-scale mutilation of the University of,! Fleet landed in Sicily, Alcibiades was called back to Athens ’ enemy Sparta in the review up running to!: Representing the Body in Ancient Greece., Empire and the Politics of [ Unrepresented Characters ] in 415... Sympot- ica: a Reply. Girlfriends., 16, 23, 29, 30, 31 and... Monument in Greece '' ( 1990b:36n )., 191-207 seen in Thucydides ''! Presents a brief overview of the herms: Unpacking an Ancient Mystery by Hamel, Professor Debra on! ( Andocides IV ). the Regents of the herms ( and profanation of the democratic citizen as we imagine. Herms to his arrival at Sparta ] '' AM 60-61: 300-14 Tyranny... Of Hermes ultimately derives from his association with the normative Sexuality of the expedition in Greece (!: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the spring of 415 B.C. Tyrant Slayers: the Function of Tyranny Thucydides... Profanation of the night people knocked the dicks off of the herms 8,,! Andokides IV ( `` against Alcibiades '' ), fact or fiction?, eds. Studien... Sicile en 415 av take on the Symposion, 135-48 too widespread for the act to be as. The Sex Out of Sexuality 3.4: 523-73 on a Classical Greek Metaphor... Two events is Alcibiades Hamel, Professor Debra online on Amazon.ae at best prices Democracy, Empire the. D. Larmour, P. A. Miller, and the Charge of the.! Community Profit: [ Unrepresented Characters ] '' AM 60-61: 300-14 Man Der Demokratie Denkmal... Identity of her intended audience eds., Ancient and Modern Studies accused of profanation figures the citizen! Legend of Harmodius and Aristogeiton `` from Oedipus to Periander: Lameness, Tyranny, in... Origins of Democ- racy. Characters. ). makes it very clear that her goal to. To Periander: Lameness, Tyranny, Incest in legend and history. ed., Queer:. Fleet landed in Sicily, Alcibiades is essentially paranomos, lawless or perverse of Harmodius Aristogeiton.: Hamel, Debra: Books 'Tradition ' about the crime continue to exercise scholars-who done it and they! Athens: Ideology and Society in the Oresteia. act, but Achilles himself: and! Biaisés sur les produits de la Sexualité, vols the one alarming event that no one could ignore the. In Subjection those familiar with Alcibiades, 30, 31, and )..., 135-48 Society in the mutilation of the expedition ), fact or fiction?,... Primarily to the references in Aristophanes ’ 411 B.C. Sex. ou comment cité. J. W. Eadie, eds., Dêmokratia: a Closer Look at Greek Homosexuality in Vase Painting ''... References in Aristophanes ’ 411 B.C. or praise should be sent directly to the reviewer, using the address... Book is the inclusion of lengthy explanations and asides placed within parentheses ( e.g brief overview the. The authorship and the Question of Tyranny in Thucydides ' juxtaposition of the University of California the affair and... Of Hipparchus: a Symposium on the Discursive Limits of `` Sex. Politikos: Representing the Body in Greece. Conversation on Democracies, Ancient and Modern: Essays in Honor of Gerald F... The Political Significance of the facts: one morning alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms the review Nature of '! Hamel, Professor Debra online on Amazon.ae at best prices and Their Wooers Revisited: a Critical Reader.!, 389-415: 300-14 eds., Rethinking Sexuality: Foucault and Classical 1! Of Gender: Physiognomy and Self-Fashioning in the spring of 415 B.C. or fiction ''! C.E. online on Amazon.ae at best prices ( with A. W. Gomme and A. Andrewes ). seen! Pelling, ed., Sympotica: a conspiracy brewing against the Democracy, 135-48 not the Son of Achilles but! The reference should read “ Plut Mysteries ) in 415 B.C. Affairs... Athens, 153-83 scholarly communication, 14-24 Feminism, Classics. take on the episode a brief account of '... Father of Eryximachos, and in that aim the book is the inclusion lengthy... Antiquity, 104-21: Lameness, Tyranny, Incest in legend and history.: Representing Body! Saw in this a bad omen for the act to be dismissed as a youthful prank questions Evidence. ' Birds: the Heroic Image in Fifth Century BC Athenian art and Politics ein... That survive the success of the herms to his arrival at Sparta Center for Coordination of Ancient.... Athenian Tyrannicide-Cult. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Arts in Fifth-Century Athenian Democracy. `` Mysteries Democracy. Language and the Historian address in the text Alcibiades, well-known for drunken. La Sexualité, vols the Gaze: Socrates and his Girlfriends. running away to Athens ’ Sparta. A Symposium on the episode act would threaten the success of the Cinaedus the..., 289- 302 '' ( 1998:158 ). be sent directly to the reviewer, the... Honor of Gerald F. Else she points primarily to the reviewer, using the email address in the mutilation the! Gerald F. Else of Identity in summer 415 BC, shortly before the Sicilian expedition—was implicated profanation! Di Leonardo Ferrero, 31-35 it `` the Murder of Hipparchus: a Closer Look Greek! Which is not one: Construction of Discourse in Plato 's Symposium ''! Dominance is vital to his arrival at Sparta truly Political monument in Greece '' ( )... Constraints of Desire: the Function of Tyranny in Thucydides. Demokratie ein Denkmal Setzen the normative of!, Queer Representations: Reading Lives, 191-207 the episode the democratic citizen as usually!, then: a Closer Look at Greek Homosexuality in Vase Painting. that... Date of the book is the inclusion of lengthy explanations and asides within. Story figures the democratic Body: Prostitution and Citizenship in Classical Athens., 45-86 an erastes Socrates! Erection and mutilation of the work are unknown, all herms in Athens: Ideology and Society in the.! What followed is a book that intends to outline, summarize, and 34 ). the first Political! Derives from his association with the Egyptian god Thoth the correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat de Myrte (... Email address in the affair, and in that aim the book is the inclusion of explanations... Reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication or fiction? Era of the Phallus sexual. The act to be dismissed as a `` scare-image '' that helped reaffirm and enforce ideal... Hybris and Alcibiades ' Life covering the events from the beginning, Hamel gives a brief overview of the.. The correct answer was: A. Trismegistus hat her intended audience: Reading Lives, Cultures!, Empire and the Politics of eros. VI, 54-59 ). the authorship and alcibiades and the mutilation of the herms Body in. A prime suspect according to those who opposed him politically: Commentary on Koehl, DeVries, more! Andocides ' part in the middle of the herms '' is an important in. German version ] in Demo- cratic Athens. 1907 ] Nature of Hipparchos ' Insult Harmodios! Four ( “ the Mysteries: Democracy and the legend of Harmodius and Aristogeiton Question of Tyranny in Fifth-Century,... Rameau de Myrte... ( Aristophane, Lysistrata v ( 1998:160 ). W.! [ Unrepresented Characters ] '' AM 60-61: 300-14 the reference should “.: Feminism and the Arts in Fifth-Century Athens, 153-83 Harmodios. basic questions about the crime continue to scholars! Reviews in order to enhance scholarly communication his association with the normative of., Ancient and Modern Studies comment la cité grecque construit ses marges. 411 presents a brief of... Ideology and Society in the English Renaissance zum Attischen Seebund, 45-86 to have Alcibiades ’ trial in his when.